Uber v. City of Seattle (9th Cir., 2026): Gig-Worker Deactivation Rules Survive First Amendment
In Uber Technologies, Inc. v. City of Seattle, the Ninth Circuit affirmed a district court’s refusal to preliminarily enjoin Seattle’s App-Based Worker Deactivation Rights Ordinance. The court held that Uber and Instacart were unlikely to succeed on their First Amendment and vagueness challenges. The amended opinion replaces one filed on March 4, 2026. Judge Bennett dissented in part.
Assuming the ordinance regulates speech at all, a requirement that gig platforms give workers a written deactivation policy reasonably related to safe and efficient operations regulates commercial speech and likely survives First Amendment review. Because the companies were unlikely to succeed on the merits, denying a preliminary injunction was not an abuse of discretion.
Background
Seattle enacted the App-Based Worker Deactivation Rights Ordinance in 2023. It applies to “network companies” that connect customers with temporary app-based workers, such as delivery drivers and personal shoppers. It prohibits “unwarranted deactivations” of those workers’ accounts. Rideshare drivers are excluded.
Uber, with its subsidiary Portier, LLC, and Instacart did not challenge the deactivation prohibition itself. Instead, they targeted section 8.40.050 of the Seattle Municipal Code. That section requires a network company to inform workers in writing of its deactivation policy. It also requires the policy to be “reasonably related” to the company’s “safe and efficient operations.”
The ordinance lists eight examples of policies that fail that test. One example is deactivation based solely on aggregate customer ratings.
Uber sought a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction in the Western District of Washington shortly before the ordinance took effect. It argued that the ordinance compels speech in violation of the First Amendment and is unconstitutionally vague. Instacart intervened.
The district court denied relief. It found any effect on speech incidental to the ordinance’s regulation of conduct. A stipulated stay is in place while the appeals are pending.
What the Court Held on the First Amendment Claims
The panel reviewed the denial for abuse of discretion and the underlying legal questions de novo. It did not decide whether the ordinance regulates speech at all. Instead, it held that any speech involved is commercial speech: communications to temporary workers about the terms of engagement, including when their accounts may be deactivated. The court relied on its precedent treating hiring-related communications as commercial.
The court distinguished NetChoice, LLC v. Bonta and X Corp. v. Bonta. In those cases, social media companies had to file reports with the government on controversial public issues. Here, the ordinance governs only internal communications between a company and its workers—which the court likened to a modern version of familiar workplace disclosure laws.
The court then applied the Zauderer standard for compelled commercial disclosures. It held that the written-notice requirement is reasonably related to Seattle’s interest in worker health and safety, purely factual, and uncontroversial. It noted that companies may voice disagreement alongside their policies. It also found that a single webpage can satisfy the requirement, so the requirement is not unduly burdensome.
The court next addressed the “reasonably related” standard. It concluded that the standard regulates, at most, speech related to conduct Seattle has made unlawful—unwarranted deactivations. That speech fails the threshold of the more demanding Central Hudson test the companies invoked. The court reasoned that the ordinance therefore also passes the more permissive Zauderer standard.
What the Court Held on Vagueness
The companies argued that “reasonable” gives inadequate guidance and that the eight examples contradict one another. The court disagreed. It called reasonableness a well-established legal standard. It also pointed to the ordinance’s text, which narrows the term—for instance, by barring deactivation based solely on customer ratings while allowing review of accompanying comments.
The court found that the examples share common threads, such as safety. They include carve-outs for “egregious misconduct” and for more than three moving violations or at-fault collisions in three years. The court held that a person of ordinary intelligence would understand what the ordinance requires, whether or not that person agrees with it.
The Partial Dissent
Judge Bennett agreed that the ordinance is not vague. He would have held, however, that it does compel speech. He noted that the written-policy requirement is enforceable on its own. Until June 1, 2027, it is also the only part of the ordinance the city may enforce through fines. In his view, the required policies reflect contested judgments about balancing safety and efficiency, not purely factual information.
He also viewed the unlawful-activity threshold as part of Central Hudson only, not Zauderer. Finding at least serious questions on the merits, he would have vacated and remanded for the district court to reweigh all four preliminary-injunction factors.
What This Means for You
This decision addresses whether a local law governing how gig platforms deactivate app-based workers may require written deactivation policies “reasonably related” to safe and efficient operations. At the preliminary-injunction stage, the court concluded that such requirements are likely consistent with the First Amendment and are not unconstitutionally vague.
Mediating a dispute that turns on this? Employment mediation →
These summaries are general information about developments in California employment law. They are not legal advice and don’t create a mediator–client relationship. For guidance on a specific matter, consult a qualified attorney.