ALADS v. Superior Court (2d Dist., 2026): Sheriff’s Chiefs Couldn’t Bind County to Settlements
In Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs v. Superior Court, the Second District Court of Appeal held that Los Angeles County was not bound by settlements in which sheriff’s department chiefs agreed to reinstate three discharged deputies while their civil service appeals were pending. The court treated an arguably untimely appeal as a petition for writ of mandate and then denied the petition, leaving the dismissal of the deputies’ claims in place.
A sheriff’s authority to appoint, suspend, and discharge does not imply power to bind Los Angeles County to settlements that rescind or modify discipline during civil service appeals. Absent a delegation from the board or authority conferred by law under section 23005, such settlements do not bind the county.
Background
In or about 2017, three Los Angeles County sheriff’s deputies received notices of intent to discharge and were later fired for alleged misconduct. Each appealed to the Los Angeles County Civil Service Commission. In 2019, while those appeals were pending, each deputy signed a settlement with a department chief that purported to reduce the discipline and reinstate the deputy.
The county refused to honor the agreements, which the Board of Supervisors had not approved. The deputies and their union, the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs (ALADS), sued to enforce the settlements through mandamus, breach of contract, and promissory estoppel claims. They also sought a declaration that the county must honor settlements the department reaches during commission appeals.
In a 2023 decision in the same case, the Court of Appeal held that county counsel does not have exclusive authority to settle commission appeals. It found, however, that the plaintiffs had not yet shown the chiefs had that authority, and it sent the case back so they could amend their pleading.
On remand, the Los Angeles County Superior Court sustained the county’s demurrer to the fourth amended petition without leave to amend. It concluded the plaintiffs still had not shown the chiefs acted “under authority of the board or authority conferred by law” under Government Code section 23005.
Why the Court Treated the Appeal as a Writ Petition
On July 7, 2025, the trial court filed and served a signed order dismissing the action, the same day it directed the parties to submit a proposed judgment. It then entered a separate judgment on August 11. Measured from the dismissal order, the plaintiffs’ October notice of appeal arguably came too late.
Because the trial court’s steps appear to have led the parties to believe the dismissal order was not the final judgment, the Court of Appeal found the circumstances unusual enough to treat the appeal as a writ petition. That allowed it to reach the merits.
What the Court Held on Settlement Authority
Reviewing the demurrer ruling de novo, the court started from section 23005, which allows a county to act only through its board of supervisors or through agents and officers acting under the board’s authority or authority conferred by law. The plaintiffs offered four sources of authority for the chiefs’ settlements. The court rejected each one.
First, the court held that the sheriff’s power to appoint, suspend, and discharge does not carry an implied power to rescind or modify discipline while a commission appeal is pending. The county’s civil service system divides authority among the sheriff, the director of personnel, and the commission to promote competence and guard against favoritism. An implied settlement power would upset that balance.
The court added that such a power could let department officials commit the county to back pay, even though county counsel cannot settle a claim above $20,000 without board approval. It also noted that department officials remain free to bring new facts to the commission or to recommend a settlement to the board.
Second, a department manual provision requiring a chief to consult a constitutional policing advisor and obtain the undersheriff’s concurrence before settling did not supply authority. The plaintiffs did not show that the board delegated settlement power, or that the department representatives who allegedly agreed with ALADS in 2018 to adopt the provision had authority to bind the county to it.
Third, an alleged practice dating to 1980 of captains and chiefs settling discipline cases without board approval did not bind the county. The plaintiffs never showed that ending the practice would trigger the meet-and-confer duty of the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act. Fourth, an unpublished 2013 decision upholding a different ALADS settlement did not collaterally estop the county, because it decided a different issue.
What the Court Held on the Remaining Claims
The promissory estoppel claims failed along with the contract and mandamus claims. As the court held in 2023, estoppel cannot override the public’s interest in limiting who may incur liability on the county’s behalf. That the trial court had not separately addressed those claims did not matter, because an appellate court reviews the result, not the rationale.
Any error in sustaining the demurrer to the declaratory relief claim was harmless because the underlying claim was legally untenable. The plaintiffs did not challenge the denial of leave to amend, so that issue was forfeited. The petition was denied, with costs awarded to the county.
What This Means for You
This decision clarifies that, under Government Code section 23005, Los Angeles County sheriff’s department officials have no implied authority to bind the county to settlements that reinstate employees or reduce their discipline while civil service appeals are pending. It addresses disputes over the enforceability of settlements negotiated by public-agency managers without approval from the governing body or another lawful source of authority.
Mediating a dispute that turns on this? Employment mediation →
These summaries are general information about developments in California employment law. They are not legal advice and don’t create a mediator–client relationship. For guidance on a specific matter, consult a qualified attorney.